Joining my liquid liner collection is the Benefit They're Real Push Up Liner. This liner has a slanting tip (very different from the felt tip liquid liners I have used before). You need to rotate the bottom of the liner tube so that fresh product is PUSHED UP to the tip of the nib. Tip of the nib. God, that rhymes. Anyway, this means you get fresh product at each use. This eyeliner is great for doing a whole winged liner/cat eye. The pigmentation of the eyeliner is quite good, a deep, dark black. And it stays on all day without smudging.

If you are a liquid liner fanatic, definitely give this one a try. The They're Real Mascara and Push Up Liner have become two of my favorite eye products from Benefit.